Daniel Craig

Benoit Blanc

Josh O'Connor

Fr. Jud Duplenticy

Glenn Close

Martha Delacroix

Josh Brolin

Mons. Jefferson Wicks

Mila Kunis

Chief Geraldine Scott

Jeremy Renner

Dr. Nat Sharp

Kerry Washington

Vera Draven, Esq.

Andrew Scott

Lee Ross

Cailee Spaeny

Simone Vivane

Daryl McCormack

Cy Draven

Thomas Haden Church

Samson Holt

Jeffrey Wright

Bp. Langstrom

Annie Hamilton

Grace Wicks

James Faulkner

Rev. Prentice Wicks

Bridget Everett

Louise

Noah Segan

Nikolai

Jamie Karitzis

Geraldine's Deputy

Kit Burden

Dcn. Clark

Gavin Spokes

Rev. Frank

Paul Hilton

Rev. Delancy

Joseph Gordon-Levitt

Baseball Announcer (voice)

Cecilia Blair

Young Martha

Georgie Drain

Young Wicks

Bertie Drain

Young Wicks

Leo Abelo Perry

Young Cy

Ray Bolton

Vera's Father

Nicola Hughes

Darla

Laura Elsworthy

Single Mother

Daphne Cheung

Masked Woman

Hugh Wyld

Upset Couple #1

Matthew Jacobs Morgan

Upset Couple #2

Kerry Frances

Tammy

Ian Porter

Eddie

Dan Chariton

Deputy Roscoe Pascoe

Eddie Gorodetsky

James

Bill Davey

Cy's Attorney